Comparisons
Side-by-side truck accessory comparisons, with weather sealing or fit, durability and value scored for both products so you can see exactly where each one wins.
← All reviews
ComparisonKodiak Canvas Truck Tent vs Napier Truck Tent · 7.3 / 6.9
Kodiak Canvas vs Napier truck tent: floorless canvas or a floored polyester tent, weather, poles, clamps, setup time and which beds each fits.
ComparisonRetraxPRO XR vs RetraxONE XR · 6.4 / 5.9
RetraxPRO XR vs RetraxONE XR: our pick, what aluminum, 500 lb and a lifetime warranty buy over polycarbonate, leaks, racks and fit by truck.
ComparisonRoll-N-Lock M-Series vs RetraxPRO XR · 6.3 / 6.4
Roll-N-Lock M-Series vs RetraxPRO XR: canister size, T-slot rails, latches, water records, warranties and fit by truck for two retractables.
ComparisonBAKFlip MX4 vs Gator EFX · 5.9 / 6.3
BAKFlip MX4 vs Gator EFX: our pick, full fold or two-thirds, leak risk, 400 vs 300 lb ratings, 5 vs 2 year warranties and fit by truck.
ComparisonAccess LOMAX vs BAKFlip MX4 · 6.4 / 5.9
Access LOMAX vs BAKFlip MX4: which hard tri-fold keeps the bed drier, lift-off vs fold-to-cab access, drain tubes, warranties and fit by truck.
ComparisonTruXedo Lo Pro vs TruXedo TruXport · 6.5 / 6.8
TruXedo TruXport vs Lo Pro: rails on top or inside the bed, which keeps it drier, tension, care rules, warranties, fit by truck and our pick.
ComparisonAccess LOMAX vs WeatherTech AlloyCover · 6.4 / 6.2
Access LOMAX vs WeatherTech AlloyCover: warranty terms, who installs it, fit by truck, leak and wear records, and which hard tri-fold to buy.
ComparisonAndersen No-Sway vs Equal-i-zer 4-Point · 6.9 / 7.2
Andersen No-Sway vs Equal-i-zer 4-point: weight transfer, sway control, hookup, noise, how each one fails, and our pick by tongue weight.
ComparisonBAKFlip MX4 vs BAKFlip F1 · 5.9 / 6.3
BAKFlip MX4 vs F1: our pick, FRP vs aluminum panels, the two-thirds fold, leak records, which costs less and fit for each truck.
ComparisonBAKFlip G2 vs Gator EFX · 6.1 / 6.3
BAKFlip G2 vs Gator EFX: our pick, full fold or two-thirds, the G2 tailgate step, leaks, 3 vs 2 year warranties and fit by truck.
ComparisonWeatherTech FloorLiner vs TuxMat · 6.3 / 7.0
WeatherTech FloorLiner vs TuxMat: our pick, tray capacity vs sidewall coverage, curling vs stitching, winter footing and fit by truck cab.
ComparisonHusky WeatherBeater vs TuxMat · 7.5 / 7.0
Husky WeatherBeater vs TuxMat: our pick, hard tray vs foam-core mat, dead pedal, winter grip, durability, warranties and fit by truck cab.
ComparisonBAKFlip MX4 vs LEER HF650M · 5.9 / 6.6
BAKFlip MX4 vs LEER HF650M: our pick, the latch, leaks and drain tubes, four panels or three, 450 vs 400 lb, warranties and fit by truck.
ComparisonTyger T3 Soft Tri-Fold vs TruXedo Lo Pro · 6.9 / 6.5
Tyger T3 vs TruXedo Lo Pro: our pick, tri-fold or roll-up bed access, tension and leaks, warranty rules, install and fit by truck.
ComparisonBAKFlip MX4 vs UnderCover Ultra Flex · 5.9 / 6.6
BAKFlip MX4 vs UnderCover Ultra Flex: our pick, leak records, how each folds, the same 400 lb rating and 5-year warranty, racks and fit by truck.
ComparisonTruXedo Sentry CT vs BAK Revolver X4s · 7.0 / 6.4
TruXedo Sentry CT vs BAK Revolver X4s: our pick, canvas or vinyl top, leak records, install fuss, tool-free removal and fit by truck.
ComparisonUnderCover Ultra Flex vs UnderCover Armor Flex · 6.6 / 6.3
Ultra Flex vs Armor Flex: our pick, what the coated top buys, hail and scratch evidence, leak records, install time and fit by truck.
ComparisonBAKFlip MX4 vs BAKFlip G2 · 5.9 / 6.1
BAKFlip MX4 vs G2: our pick, the tailgate step the G2 adds, 400 vs 300 lb, 5 vs 3 years, leak records and fitment for each truck.
ComparisonHusky WeatherBeater vs WeatherTech FloorLiner · 7.5 / 6.3
Husky WeatherBeater vs WeatherTech FloorLiner: our pick, dead pedal vs wall coverage, curling, grip and price by cab for F-150, T1XX and Tacoma.