Yakima OverHaul HD vs Xtrusion Overland XTR1
 |  | |
|---|---|---|
| Our score | 7.0 | 6.8 |
| Fit & load | 7.0 | 7.2 |
| Durability | 7.2 | 6.8 |
| Value | 6.6 | 6.2 |
| Rated load | 300 lb (off-road dynamic, rack included; 500 lb on-road, 800 lb parked static; less on Tonneau Kit 1) | 450 lb (off-road dynamic; 850 lb on-road dynamic, 1,550 lb parked static; the bed-rail limit governs if lower) |
| Warranty | Limited lifetime, original buyer from an authorized seller; excludes rough off-road driving, commercial use and car-wash damage | Limited lifetime on structure for the original buyer; 2 years on finish and hardware (the install guide still prints 1 year) |
| Material | Powder-coated aluminum towers with steel hardware; HD Bars sold separately | 1530 T-slot aluminum extrusion with 6061-T6 billet corner brackets |
| Confirmed listings for | Gen14 F-150, Gen13 F-150, T1XX Silverado / Sierra, DT Ram 1500, 4th Gen Tacoma, 3rd Gen Tacoma, 3rd Gen Tundra, Maverick, 3rd Gen Colorado / Canyon, 6th Gen Ranger | Gen14 F-150, Gen13 F-150, T1XX Silverado / Sierra, DT Ram 1500, 4th Gen Tacoma, 3rd Gen Tacoma, 3rd Gen Tundra, 6th Gen Ranger, Maverick, 3rd Gen Colorado / Canyon |
| Owners say | Twenty-one owners name the HD in their own posts and seven more describe an OverHaul in threads about it, on Tacomas, Tundras, Mavericks, a Sierra 1500, a Ram and a Ford Tremor among others. None describes a structural failure. | Ten owners name the XTR1 in their own posts: one on a Maverick, one on a Colorado, two on Tacomas, one on a Silverado, two on trucks a generation older than the ones we cover and three who don't name the truck. One more, who posted a discount code for the rack, is left out. |
| Our verdict | The rack that comes off between trips and adjusts on the truck; plan around 300 lb off-road with the rack itself counted. | A no-drill clamp-on rack that rides over a roll-up or Retrax cover; order early and plan around the 450 lb off-road rating. |
| Read our reviewCheck price on Amazon | Read our reviewSee it at the maker |
Fit varies by generation, cab, bed length and options. Open the review for the exact listing for your truck before you buy.