WeatherTech FloorLiner vs TuxMat Custom Floor Mats
 |  | |
|---|---|---|
| Our score | 6.3 | 7.0 |
| Fit & coverage | 6.8 | 7.7 |
| Durability | 6.0 | 6.5 |
| Value | 6.0 | 6.5 |
| Install time | 5 min | |
| Warranty | Limited lifetime, original buyer and vehicle | Limited lifetime against defects, not transferable |
| Material | Rigid laser-measured liner | Textured vinyl top over an EVA foam core |
| Confirmed listings for | Gen14 F-150, Gen13 F-150, T1XX Silverado / Sierra, 4th Gen Tacoma | Gen14 F-150, T1XX Silverado / Sierra, DT Ram 1500, 4th Gen Tacoma, 3rd Gen Tacoma, 3rd Gen Tundra |
| Owners say | Long-term owners praise the fit, the sill contour and sets that lasted up to 15 years, and eight owners who've had both brands say it fit better than the Husky, against five who say the reverse. The most common complaint by far is edges that curl or warp over time. | Most of the more than 40 floor-mat owners drive cars and SUVs; five drive trucks. Coverage is the reason they give most: twelve name it as why they bought TuxMat or rate it above Husky, WeatherTech or the factory mats. |
| Our verdict | A crisp-fitting rigid liner that costs too much for what it does better than the Husky. Watch the edges for curl. | The most coverage of any liner we have reviewed, with a softer, less slick top that holds less in a big spill. |
| Read our reviewCheck price on Amazon | Read our reviewCheck price on Amazon |
Fit varies by generation, cab, bed length and options. Open the review for the exact listing for your truck before you buy.