Rough Country Rubber Bed Mat vs BedRug XLT Bed Mat

	Rough Country Rubber Bed Mat	BedRug XLT Bed Mat
Our score	7.6	7.6
Fit & coverage	7.2	7.8
Durability	8.0	8.0
Value	7.6	6.8
Install time	10 min
Warranty	Limited lifetime against manufacturer defects	Limited lifetime, original buyer and vehicle; ends if removed from that vehicle; not transferable
Material	3/8 in Nyracord rubber, 100% recycled, molded per truck and bed; not for drop-in liners	Polypropylene fiber top over 3/4 in closed-cell foam
Confirmed listings for	Gen14 F-150, Gen13 F-150, T1XX Silverado / Sierra, DT Ram 1500, 4th Gen Tacoma, 3rd Gen Tacoma, Maverick	Gen14 F-150, Gen13 F-150, DT Ram 1500, 3rd Gen Tundra, 4th Gen Tacoma
Owners say	Of the 74 owners who describe their own Rough Country bed mat, the large majority like it, and the praise is consistent: thick, heavy, nothing slides on it, and it holds up, with one mat at 8 years in a 2015 F-150 and nobody describing a tear or a crack. The smell is the main complaint, raised by 12 owners: for some it fades in weeks, while others still smell it after four months, six months or most of a year, sun and pressure washing included, and one found that washing off an oily film on the new mat took the smell with it.	Of the 42 owners who describe their own, most don't name the line, and every one who describes the surface describes the fiber top, not the Impact's rubber floor. Durability is the strongest theme: nobody describes one tearing or wearing through, with mats at five, six and 13 years and one past 200k miles in its second truck.
Our verdict	A thick, grippy rubber floor for less than a BedRug; give it time in open air before the smell goes under a cover.	The bed floor we would buy for clean loads under a cover that seals; skip it for weekly gravel or a leaky cover.
	Read our reviewCheck price on Amazon	Read our reviewCheck price on Amazon

Fit varies by generation, cab, bed length and options. Open the review for the exact listing for your truck before you buy.